Business News Blog. Daily Business News and information on emerging issues influencing the global economy. Welcome to the Peak Newsroom!
Friday, August 21, 2015
BOYCOTT AMAZON? IT'S NOT AN EASY CHOICE
There are plenty of examples of consumers flexing their economic muscle in response to what they see as businesses behaving badly.
Take the boycott of California grapes in the 1960s over mistreatment of farmworkers. Or the boycott of Chick-fil-A in 2012 over the fast-food chain's opposition to same-sex marriage.
So what, if anything, should be done about Amazon.com?
The world's largest e-tailer has been in hot water all week after the New York Times ran a front-page story about the company's employment practices. It included tales of workers being bullied, harassed and basically made to feel miserable. A Boston employment lawyer is reviewing the details of this case.
The enduring image from the story was that of Amazon staffers routinely breaking down in tears at their desks.
Jeff Bezos, Amazon's founder and chief executive, didn't deny the allegations. He just said this was all news to him.
"The article doesn't describe the Amazon I know or the caring Amazonians I work with every day," Bezos said in a memo to employees.
The story, he said, "claims that our intentional approach is to create a soulless, dystopian workplace where no fun is had and no laughter heard. Again, I don't recognize this Amazon, and I very much hope you don't, either." An Albany employment lawyer represents clients in employment law matters including workplace harassment, unfair labor practices, and wrongful termination claims.
Be that as it may, Amazon customers face a quandary. Do they continue shopping on the site as if nothing were amiss? Or do they respond in some way so the company understands their concern?
"These are very interesting questions," said Lars Perner, an assistant professor of marketing at USC's Marshall School of Business. "You might think about boycotting, but that's difficult given the sheer size of Amazon."
Like me, Perner is a regular Amazon customer. And like me, he's feeling conflicted about doing business with a company that may ride roughshod over its workers.
"I'm still trying to make sense of it all — what's the truth, what isn't," Perner said. "It would be very hard to give Amazon up." A Raleigh employment lawyer is following this story closely.
The story included anecdotal tales about one worker who was given a low performance rating after returning from treatment for thyroid cancer, and another with breast cancer who was put on a "performance improvement plan" — Amazon-speak for probation.
One employee was quoted as saying that she had to leave for a business trip the day after she miscarried twins. "The work is still going to need to get done," she said her boss told her.
Some consumer actions are more clear-cut than others. When Nike wearers learned in the 1990s that the company's pricey shoes were manufactured in Southeast Asian sweatshops, with some workers making as little as 14 cents an hour, a global boycott seemed reasonable.
And it succeeded. Nike, acting out of self-preservation if not moral clarity, pledged to become a leader in fair labor practices.
"The Nike product has become synonymous with slave wages, forced overtime and arbitrary abuse," then-CEO Phil Knight said in 1998. "I truly believe the American consumer doesn't want to buy products made under abusive conditions."
But does the American consumer want to buy products from a digital dynamo that pushes its employees around? Or is the American consumer willing to look the other way to keep enjoying low prices and free shipping for orders over $35?
"I don't think you'll see much of a response from Amazon customers," predicted Ann Bastianelli, senior adjunct professor of marketing at Indiana University's Kelley School of Business. "At the end of the day, people will do the most convenient thing."
That seemed to be the case in 2011 after reports that Amazon forced warehouse employees near Allentown, Pa., to work in 114-degree heat, with paramedics waiting nearby for when they'd collapse. There was a protest, and Bezos promised to install air conditioners. But it seemed as if many customers shrugged off the incident.
Bastianelli suggested that sometimes the ends justify the means. She recalled working around 1980 with Indiana's Bob Knight, who was the winningest college basketball coach at the time but also was known for his fiery temper and angry outbursts.
An irate Knight once threw a chair across the court during a 1985 game.
"I'm a big fan of Coach Knight," Bastianelli said. "The fans wanted to win, period. He could take things that were ordinary and make them extraordinary."
The same could be said of Amazon. There's no question that the company is really good at what it does. That's why Wall Street hardly flinched after this week's bad-place-to-work story ran.
And it's clear that, unpleasant though the conditions may be, Amazon is no forced-labor sweatshop for its white-collar employees. They're free to seek gigs elsewhere in the tech world.
My response as a customer, therefore, isn't to take my business elsewhere. I mean, where would I go to match Amazon's impressive service and vast inventory?
"When consumers are concerned about a company's practices or policy positions, it's more effective to make your concerns known to the company in a public way, rather than just privately boycotting the company," advised Emily Rusch, executive director of the California Public Interest Research Group. A South Jersey employment lawyer has experience defending clients in employment related matters involving instances of detrimental labor conditions or discriminatory employment practices.
This column represents my little bit. Here's how you can do yours: Bezos' email address is jeff@amazon.com — and I'm told he really reads his email.
Let him know you're not cool with the company being uncool.
I like Amazon. I want it to succeed.
But not at any cost.
Monday, August 9, 2010
Target Discovers Downside to Political Giving
The Minneapolis retailer recently donated $150,000 to a political group, Minnesota Forward, that backs pro-business candidates in statewide races, including a candidate for governor who opposes same-sex marriage. On Friday, hundreds of gay-rights supporters demonstrated outside Target stores in locations nationwide, and a petition promising a boycott, signed by more than 240,000, was delivered to Target.
The Target flap shows the potential downside for companies that want to get more involved in politics since a January Supreme Court ruling on campaign contributions. Brand-oriented companies, in particular, worry about getting embroiled in controversies that can tarnish their reputation. It is a rare political black eye for the trendy discounter, which has a track record of supporting gay causes, including extending partner health benefits to its employees.
The campaign against Target was orchestrated by liberal-advocacy group MoveOn.org. It included a note on the retailer's Facebook page that said, "Boycott Target Until They Cease Funding Anti-Gay Politics."
"We made Target the target," said Ilyse Hogue, the group's director of public advocacy. Ms. Hogue said MoveOn and its members plan to gin up bad publicity for any company venturing into political campaigning.
Target Chief Executive Gregg Steinhafel apologized in a letter to his employees Thursday, a day before the protests. "The intent of our political contribution to MN Forward was to support economic growth and job creation," he wrote. "While I firmly believe that a business climate conducive to growth is critical to our future, I realize our decision affected many of you in a way I did not anticipate, and for that I am genuinely sorry."
Target declined to address the question of whether it would withdraw the donation.
The January Supreme Courtruling, known as Citizens United, loosened restrictions on corporate and union activity in elections. The court said these entities could dip into their treasuries to pay for ads supporting or opposing candidates. Previously, they were prohibited from paying for ads directly, and could use only funds contributed by employees or members.
Democrats blasted the ruling, saying it would lead to a gusher of donations that would give companies disproportionate influence in elections. Republicans called it a win for free speech.
Despite the ruling, most corporations remain reluctant to donate money to outside political organizations. People involved in politics say most companies remain risk-averse, worried about what would happen if they supported the loser. Labor unions remain larger contributors to elections than corporations.
"It's harder to get corporations to do this than a lot of people thought it was going to be," said Vin Weber, a former Republican lawmaker from Minnesota who is now a lobbyist and political consultant. "People think that most businesses are Republican, but by and large, companies don't think that it makes much of a difference which political party controls Washington."
Minnesota Forward was created in the wake of the court decision precisely to collect donations from corporations. Established in part by the Minnesota Chamber of Commerce, it is funded by a handful of companies in the state, including Target, Best Buy and snowmobile-maker Polaris Industries.
"The group decided to create Minnesota Forward to put jobs and the economy at the top of the agenda during the 2010 campaign," said Brian McClung, who runs the organization. "We think it's appropriate that the business community weigh in about the best candidates."
Polaris didn't return a call for comment. Best Buy spokeswoman Sue Nehring Busch said: "Our political giving strategy is based solely on the need to help elect candidates who will make jobs and economic issues a top priority this election."
The organization isn't overtly partisan. It announced Thursday that it would support three GOP and three Democratic candidates in the state. Earlier, the group backed Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer, who supports a constitutional amendment protecting "traditional marriage."
Mr. McClung said his group picked candidates based on their fiscal, not social, positions. He said Minnesota Forward had raised about $1 million for its campaign and had pledges for about $1 million more.
The Target skirmish is likely to be the first in a series heading into the November elections. The court decision was a "watershed event for our members," said Ms. Hogue of MoveOn.org.
Ms. Hogue said MoveOn.org wouldn't let up until Target stops "meddling in our elections."
Mr. McClung responded: "We all lose when activists think they can shut down legitimate speech they disagree with."
Friday, March 21, 2008
Games Intact, Despite Unrest
U.S., EU Rule Out Boycott Over Tibet, Push for Dialogue
The White House and European Union sports ministers have ruled out a boycott of the Games, which are set for August in
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has called on
British Foreign Minister David Miliband echoed her call. "I very much hope that one lesson to be learned from the tragic events of the last few days is that substantive dialogue is the only way forward," he said.
Among the most-pointed official reactions to the
Any Olympic boycott and continued international criticism could spark a hardening of
"Certainly there will be resentment among the Chinese people toward countries that boycott the event. Even expressing a desire for it will upset us," said Niu Jun, a foreign-affairs professor at
The International Campaign for
Kate Saunders, a spokeswoman for the International Campaign for
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D., Calif.) has condemned Chinese actions against the protesters. She was scheduled to have an audience with the Dalai Lama in
"The Olympic Games in
The international response on
"I think this [push to boycott the opening ceremonies] will gain some momentum. The
The International Olympic Committee has already brushed off the call for a Games boycott. On March 15, President Jacques Rogge said a "boycott doesn't solve anything."
Jiang Xiaoyu, executive vice president of the Beijing Organizing Committee for the Olympic Games, said yesterday that a planned pre-Games torch relay that includes
By Jason Leow and
Wall Street

