231-922-9460 | Google +

Showing posts with label Political Contributions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Political Contributions. Show all posts

Thursday, November 4, 2010

The Great Communicators of Wall Street

The Wall Street Journal

The Financial Industry Is Reviled but It Keeps Its Influence With a Simple Message


The late, great George Carlin slayed many sacred cows in his time, but he never picked on politicians.

"Everybody complains about politicians, everyone thinks they suck," Mr. Carlin said in one of his last riffs. "Well where do you think these politicians come from? They don't fall out of the sky. They don't pass through a membrane from another reality."

And, he went on, "if you have selfish, ignorant citizens, you're gonna have selfish, ignorant leaders."

If only Mr. Carlin were alive today to see the results of Tuesday's midterm election, and the previous election for that matter, even he might be surprised at how accurate his analysis was.

American voters appear predisposed to voting emotionally. They swept Barack Obama into the White House on a goopy message of "change" and "hope" and after they got it, were so disgusted they voted overwhelmingly for a party whose only cohesive message was a declarative "we're not him."

"Garbage in, garbage out," Mr. Carlin used to say.

It is a cycle as perpetual as the two major parties' search for a simple unifying message. But not every political body is blindly grasping for the mercurial voter sentiment. U.S. corporations and Wall Street specifically, have a time-tested, clear and potent message that resonates: Greed is good.

Americans may be skeptical of big corporations and big finance, but on that point, they can relate.

Cue the reaction of Thomas Donahue, president and chief executive of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, to Tuesday's results. Voters, he said, "clearly stated that a strong and vibrant private sector is critical to reviving our economy, creating jobs, and putting us on a path to long-term growth. We will work with members of both parties who support policies that enable businesses of all sizes to do what they do best—create jobs, opportunity, and prosperity."

Mr. Donahue is onto something. While many pundits suggested the Republican swing in the House was due to a rebuke of health care, or big government, or an aloof president unsympathetic to the nation's struggles, exit polls found that while those issues mattered some they were all dwarfed by worries about the economy.

More than 80% of voters ranked the economy as the No. 1 issue affecting their voting decisions, according exit polls conducted by the Associated Press.

For them, U.S. business and Wall Street offered what the political parties couldn't or didn't: the prospect of better fortunes through business success. To get there, business needs to be freer from regulation and taxed less.

And if you don't think business interests mattered, consider that of the top 20 recipients of financial industry campaign contributions, only four lost on Tuesday: Sen. Blanche Lincoln, (D., Ark.), the influential chair of the Senate Agriculture Committee, Gov. Charlie Christ, (I., Fla.), Carly Fiorina, the Republican former chief executive of Hewlett-Packard Co.; and Alexander Giannoulias, the Illinois State treasurer who lost a senate bid to Rep. Mark Kirk, (R., Ill.).

Even among the losses, it could be argued Wall Street won a few. Mr. Kirk actually ranked fifth among the top 20 recipients of financial industry contributions while Mr. Giannoulias ranked 18th, according to OpenSecrets.org. A Wall Street-backed victory by Sen. Lincoln may have softened her tough stance on derivatives regulation, but her defeat makes the issue even more uncertain.

Moreover, if you think Wall Street is partisan to "business friendly" Republicans consider that the industry's $65 million in campaign contributions made through Oct. 13 actually were split evenly between the parties, with a slight edge to Democrats. Indeed, three of the top four recipients of financial industry cash were Democrats: New York Sens. Charles Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand and Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada.

If there is a common thread among this disparate collection it is this: Wall Street likes influential members of Congress regardless of party affiliation. It leans pro-business. Even more than that, it likes winners and the potential for influencing them.

Wall Street's record in supporting midterm winners runs afoul of an electorate cynical about lobbyists, special interests and so-called industry shills. So why the support? In a very direct way it comes down to Mr. Carlin's assessment: Selfish citizens elect selfish leaders.

Whether it be selfishness or self-interest or simple greed, most people vote based on whether or not they think a candidate will make them—not the nation, not a greater good—better off.

That is why Wall Street's message has appeal for candidates and a public imbued with the "me first" doctrine. In the end, voters are willing to live with special interest influence in Washington as long as they can get lower taxes, the new corporate headquarters in town and the jobs that come with it or credit and mortgages. The risks? That's for the other guys to deal with.

Garbage in, garbage out.

Monday, August 9, 2010

Target Discovers Downside to Political Giving

The Wall Street Journal

 
Target Corp. sought to take advantage of new campaign-finance rules, but ended up putting a bull's eye on its back.

The Minneapolis retailer recently donated $150,000 to a political group, Minnesota Forward, that backs pro-business candidates in statewide races, including a candidate for governor who opposes same-sex marriage. On Friday, hundreds of gay-rights supporters demonstrated outside Target stores in locations nationwide, and a petition promising a boycott, signed by more than 240,000, was delivered to Target.

The Target flap shows the potential downside for companies that want to get more involved in politics since a January Supreme Court ruling on campaign contributions. Brand-oriented companies, in particular, worry about getting embroiled in controversies that can tarnish their reputation. It is a rare political black eye for the trendy discounter, which has a track record of supporting gay causes, including extending partner health benefits to its employees.

The campaign against Target was orchestrated by liberal-advocacy group MoveOn.org. It included a note on the retailer's Facebook page that said, "Boycott Target Until They Cease Funding Anti-Gay Politics."

"We made Target the target," said Ilyse Hogue, the group's director of public advocacy. Ms. Hogue said MoveOn and its members plan to gin up bad publicity for any company venturing into political campaigning.

Target Chief Executive Gregg Steinhafel apologized in a letter to his employees Thursday, a day before the protests. "The intent of our political contribution to MN Forward was to support economic growth and job creation," he wrote. "While I firmly believe that a business climate conducive to growth is critical to our future, I realize our decision affected many of you in a way I did not anticipate, and for that I am genuinely sorry."

Target declined to address the question of whether it would withdraw the donation.

The January Supreme Courtruling, known as Citizens United, loosened restrictions on corporate and union activity in elections. The court said these entities could dip into their treasuries to pay for ads supporting or opposing candidates. Previously, they were prohibited from paying for ads directly, and could use only funds contributed by employees or members.

Democrats blasted the ruling, saying it would lead to a gusher of donations that would give companies disproportionate influence in elections. Republicans called it a win for free speech.

Despite the ruling, most corporations remain reluctant to donate money to outside political organizations. People involved in politics say most companies remain risk-averse, worried about what would happen if they supported the loser. Labor unions remain larger contributors to elections than corporations.

"It's harder to get corporations to do this than a lot of people thought it was going to be," said Vin Weber, a former Republican lawmaker from Minnesota who is now a lobbyist and political consultant. "People think that most businesses are Republican, but by and large, companies don't think that it makes much of a difference which political party controls Washington."

Minnesota Forward was created in the wake of the court decision precisely to collect donations from corporations. Established in part by the Minnesota Chamber of Commerce, it is funded by a handful of companies in the state, including Target, Best Buy and snowmobile-maker Polaris Industries.

"The group decided to create Minnesota Forward to put jobs and the economy at the top of the agenda during the 2010 campaign," said Brian McClung, who runs the organization. "We think it's appropriate that the business community weigh in about the best candidates."

Polaris didn't return a call for comment. Best Buy spokeswoman Sue Nehring Busch said: "Our political giving strategy is based solely on the need to help elect candidates who will make jobs and economic issues a top priority this election."

The organization isn't overtly partisan. It announced Thursday that it would support three GOP and three Democratic candidates in the state. Earlier, the group backed Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer, who supports a constitutional amendment protecting "traditional marriage."

Mr. McClung said his group picked candidates based on their fiscal, not social, positions. He said Minnesota Forward had raised about $1 million for its campaign and had pledges for about $1 million more.

The Target skirmish is likely to be the first in a series heading into the November elections. The court decision was a "watershed event for our members," said Ms. Hogue of MoveOn.org.

Ms. Hogue said MoveOn.org wouldn't let up until Target stops "meddling in our elections."

Mr. McClung responded: "We all lose when activists think they can shut down legitimate speech they disagree with."