231-922-9460 | Google +

Showing posts with label Teachers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teachers. Show all posts

Friday, September 16, 2011

Teacher Evaluations Evaluated

Story first appeared in the Wall Street Journal.
Teacher evaluations for years were based on brief classroom observations by the principal. But now, prodded by President Barack Obama's $4.35 billion Race to the Top program, at least 26 states have agreed to judge teachers based, in part, on results from their students' performance on standardized tests.
So with millions of teachers back in the classroom, many are finding their careers increasingly hinge on obscure formulas.
The metric created by Value-Added Research Center, a nonprofit housed at the University of Wisconsin-Madison's School of Education, is a new kind of report card that attempts to gauge how much of students' growth on tests is attributable to the teacher.
For the first time this year, teachers in Rhode Island and Florida will see their evaluations linked to the complex metric. Louisiana and New Jersey will pilot the formulas this year and roll them out next school year. At least a dozen other states and school districts will spend the year finalizing their teacher-rating formulas.
Rob Meyer, the bowtie-wearing economist who runs the Value-Added Research Center, known as VARC, and calls his statistical model a well-crafted recipe said they have to deliver quality and speed, because schools need the data now.
VARC is one of at least eight entities developing such models.
Supporters say the new measuring sticks could improve U.S. educational performance by holding teachers accountable for students' progress. Teachers unions and other critics say the tests' measurements are narrow and that the teachers' scores jump around too much, casting doubt on the validity of the formulas.
Janice Poda, strategic-initiatives director for the Council of Chief State School Officers, said education officials are trying to make sense of the complicated models. States have to trust the vendor is designing a system that is fair and, right now, a lot of the state officials simply don't have the information they need, she said.
Bill Sanders, who developed the nation's first model to measure teachers' effect on student test scores, advises caution. People smell the money and there are lots of people rushing out with unsophisticated formulas, said Mr. Sanders, who works as a senior researcher at software firm SAS Institute Inc., which competes with VARC for contracts.
In general, the models use a student's score on, say, a fourth-grade math test to predict how she or he would perform on the fifth-grade test. Some groups, such as VARC, adjust those raw test scores to control for students' outside factors, such as income or race. The actual fifth-grade score is then compared with the expected score, which then translates into the measure of the teacher's added value.
The teacher's overall effectiveness with every student in the classroom is boiled down to one number to rate them from least effective to most effective.
For states and school districts, deciding which vendor to use is critical. The metrics differ in substantial ways and those distinctions can have a significant influence on whether a teacher is rated superior or subpar.
Teaching Moments
1982 Bill Sanders, a professor at the University of Tennessee, begins building value-added models to measure teachers' impact on student achievement. By 1992, Tennessee education officials adopt a refined version of the model to evaluate the state's schools.
2002 President George W. Bush's No Child Left Behind law goes into effect, providing data that can be used to evaluate students' growth.
2005 The University of Wisconsin's Value-Added Research Center, or VARC, is formed by Rob Meyer.
2006 The federal Teacher Incentive Fund begins issuing grants to school systems and states to develop programs to award teachers who raise test scores.
2008 The Houston Independent School District begins issuing bonuses to teachers with high value-added rankings.
2009-2010 New York City starts including value-added data in decisions about whether to grant tenure to teachers.
2010 The $4.35 billion Race to the Top grants create incentives for states to adopt new education policies, including linking test scores to teacher evaluations.
Summer 2010 The Washington, D.C., school district uses value-added data to evaluate and fire teachers.
In August, a New York State Supreme Court judge invalidated a vote by state education officials that would have let districts base 40% of teacher evaluations on state test scores, after the state teachers unions sued saying the law allowed for only 20%. The Los Angeles teachers union has sued to stop the district from launching a pilot program that would grade some teachers using a VARC formula.
Until this year, only a few districts used value-added data. Washington, D.C., used it to fire about 60 teachers; New York City employed it to deny tenure to what it considered underperforming teachers; and Houston relied on it to award bonuses.
Michelle Rhee, who instituted a tough evaluation system when she was schools chancellor in Washington, said she took over a district where many students failed achievement exams, yet virtually every teacher was rated effective.
Ms. Rhee, who now heads StudentsFirst, a nonprofit advocate for education overhauls said while it's not a perfect measure, it was a much fairer, more transparent and consistent way to evaluate teachers.
Andy Dewey, an 11th-grade history teacher in Houston, is not a fan. He saw his score bounce from a positive rating in the 2008-09 school year to a negative rating the following year, decreasing his bonus by about $2,300.
In New York City, value-added data has been used for the last two years by principals only to make teacher tenure decisions. Last year, 3% of teachers did not receive tenure protection based, in part, on that data. A new state law, passed in an effort to compete for Race the Top, requires the data become an official part of every teacher evaluation.
At Frederick Douglass Academy in Harlem, principal Gregory Hodge uses the value-added results to alter instruction, move teachers to new classroom assignments and pair weak students with the highest performing teachers. Mr. Hodge said the data for teachers generally aligns with his classroom observations. He said it's confirming what an experienced principal knows.

Thursday, June 3, 2010

D.C. Teachers' Union Ratifies Contract, Basing Pay on Results, not Seniority

The Washington Post
Washington Teachers' Union President George Parker calls the ratification of the contract "a great day for teachers and students." (Susan Biddle/the Washington Post) 
 
 
District teachers ratified a new contract Wednesday that dramatically expands Chancellor Michelle A. Rhee's ability to remove poor educators and places Washington on a growing list of cities and states that have established classroom results, not seniority, as the standard by which teachers are paid.

Members of the Washington Teachers' Union approved the pact 1,412 to 425 after a two-week voting period. The agreement now goes to the D.C. Council, where it is expected to be swiftly approved.

The contract, a product of nearly 2 1/2 years of contentious negotiations, combines a rich traditional financial package with unorthodox initiatives historically resisted by unionized teachers. It includes a five-year, 21.6 percent increase in base pay that will boost the average annual salary of a D.C. educator from $67,000 to about $81,000 and gives the city's public school teachers salaries comparable to those in surrounding suburban districts, according to a union survey. The payday stands out amid a wave of deep school budget cuts across the country. New York Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg said Wednesday, for instance, that his city will eliminate raises for its public school teachers and principals over the next two years to avoid deep job reductions.

Although the contract breaks new ground for the District, the extraordinary pace of change in national education policy has in some ways overtaken the document. When negotiations started in late 2007, the concepts embedded in Rhee's contract and evaluation proposals -- performance pay linked to test score growth, weakening of seniority and tenure -- were far more politically polarizing. As both sides hammered away at the bargaining table, these issues were swept into the mainstream by the Obama administration. Its "Race to the Top" grant competition encourages states to revamp their laws to incorporate some of these ideas. Several states, including Colorado and New York, have passed laws addressing these issues in the hope of snagging some of the $3.4 billion on the table.

"The ideas have gained currency at the national level," said former Baltimore mayor Kurt L. Schmoke, who is dean of Howard University's law school and was a mediator between the union and the District. "What was seen as bold is now reform, not revolution."

The highlights

A voluntary performance pay program to begin this fall could add $20,000 to $30,000 to D.C. teachers' salaries, based on significant improvement in student test scores and other yet-to-be specified criteria. The system, to be financed for the first three years under a controversial arrangement with private foundations approved by District Chief Financial Officer Natwar M. Gandhi, could raise total compensation for some instructors to $140,000, officials estimate. Although cities such as Denver have had incentive pay programs for several years, none promise the kind of money that Rhee says she is prepared to pay. For teachers who enter the plan, it means no longer having to invest 10 to 15 years in a lockstep pay schedule to command a significant income.

The contract -- in tandem with a new teacher evaluation system that will use growth in test scores as one benchmark -- will also dilute job security for some educators. It allows principals to use job performance, instead of seniority, as the chief determinant when reducing staff because of declining enrollment or program changes.

Under a "mutual consent" clause, displaced teachers who used to be assigned to new schools -- whether principals wanted them or not -- will no longer be guaranteed spots in the system and must find administrators willing to take them. Teachers with good evaluations who are unable to find a job have a year's grace period, at full pay, to continue the search. They can also opt for a $25,000 buyout or early retirement with full benefits if they have 20 or more years of service.

Both sides nevertheless expressed satisfaction with the final version of the accord.

"I am very pleased with the contract," Rhee said. "It strikes a great balance between making teachers understand that we very much value and support the work they do every day and on the administrative side giving us the tools we need to staff the schools effectively." Washington Teachers' Union President George Parker called it "a great day for teachers and students."

Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, who shared negotiating responsibilities with Parker, was less effusive. She said she was pleased that after months of divisiveness, the two sides found common ground in "wanting teachers to be the best they could be" with provisions for increased professional development and classroom resources.

But the agreement reflects the top-down character of school governance in the District, where, she said, Rhee and Mayor Adrian M. Fenty (D) do not recognize the importance of collaboration with teachers.

"At the end of the day, this is still one of the industrial model contracts where a lot of the authority is reposed in the chancellor herself," said Weingarten, adding that the union was able to incorporate checks and balances into the contract that lend more transparency to Rhee's power.

WTU General Vice President Nathan Saunders said that he continued to regard the raises in the contract as "blood money" because of Rhee's decision to lay off 266 teachers last fall.

"We have to be concerned with what happened to our neighbors," said Saunders, who is a candidate for union president. But, he added, "teachers voted for it, and I can conclude nothing more than that it was their will."

High-stakes fight


The contract was approached by both sides as much more than another collective bargaining agreement. With the involvement of Rhee and Weingarten, two of the most outspoken figures in public education, it was viewed locally and nationally as a high-stakes confrontation pitting a new generation of urban school leaders, impatient for rapid change in failing big-city systems, against the politically influential teachers union, which wanted to preserve jobs but also be seen as a force for reform.

Weingarten and union negotiators scuttled Rhee's original proposal for a two-tier plan that would have forced teachers seeking top pay levels to relinquish tenure for a year, exposing them to dismissal without the right to appeal. Rhee's plan would have required new teachers to select the higher-risk salary track.

But Rhee negotiated away relatively little of what she sought. Tenure -- granted to eligible teachers in the District after two years and assailed by Rhee as the "holy grail" of unions -- was left technically intact. But it was redefined to affirm that it is only a due-process mechanism to protect against unfair dismissal, not a guarantee of a lifetime employment.

The accord and the evaluation system give Rhee a formidable toolbox of personnel and policy rules that supporters say could help dramatically improve teaching and learning. The mutual consent provision, for example, has potentially significant implications should Rhee decide to replace or "reconstitute" some or all of the staffs at schools deemed to be failing under the federal No Child Left Behind law, something she has done in previous years.

"What Michelle has put together, no other school district has put together. It's the whole package," said Kate Walsh, executive director of the National Council on Teacher Quality, a longtime advocate for changes in how teachers are hired, trained and compensated.

Rhee benefited enormously from the District's status as a city-state, with a school system under mayoral control. She answered only to Fenty and did not have to contend with an elected school board or a state legislature -- often an important source of political support for unions. She also gained advantage from a mid-1990s law passed by Congress that gave the school system sole authority over creation of a teacher evaluation system.

It allowed Rhee to formulate the new evaluation system unilaterally last year, away from the bargaining table. The result is a new vehicle praised by supporters for its rigor and criticized by many teachers for its excessive complexity and subjectivity.

Monday, April 12, 2010

States Push to Pay Teachers Based on Performance

Associated Press

Students raise their hands in Trenise Duvernay's fourth grade math class at Alice M. Harte Charter School in New Orleans. Duvernay wants to be rewarded for helping students succeed. She is eligible for $2,000 a year or more in merit bonuses based on how well her students perform in classroom observations and on achievement tests. By Gerald Herbert, AP 

ATLANTA — For parents and politicians hungry for better schools, the idea of paying teachers more if their students perform better can seem as basic as adding two and two or spelling "cat." Yet just a handful of schools and districts around the country use such strategies. In some states, the idea is effectively illegal.

That could all be changing as the federal government wields billions of dollars in grants to lure states and school districts to try the idea. The money is persuading lawmakers around the country, while highlighting the complex problems surrounding pay-for-performance systems.

Some teachers, like Trenise Duvernay, who teaches math at Alice M. Harte Charter School in New Orleans, want to be rewarded for helping students succeed. Duvernay is eligible for $2,000 a year or more in merit bonuses based on how well her students perform in classroom observations and on achievement tests.

"It's a reward for doing what we all have a passion to do anyway — making sure our kids master the skills they need in order to be successful," Duvernay said.

Other teachers, like Debra Gunter, a middle school math teacher in Cobb County, Ga., say teachers can't control which kids walk into their classrooms.

"Your mother and father just got a divorce, your grandfather died, your boyfriend broke up with you: those kinds of life-altering events have an effect on how you do in class that day, through no fault of the teacher whatsoever," said Gunter, echoing the position espoused by major teacher unions.

Some researchers have found student achievement improves when teachers get performance bonuses. Others have found no correlation.

Matthew Springer, director of Vanderbilt University's National Center on Performance Initiatives, said the problem is that there are only a handful of valid studies, most from other countries.

"I think the jury is still out," he said.

The push for performance pay programs dates to 1950, but has mostly failed because districts and states didn't get buy-in from teachers and couldn't come up with objective ways to measure performance.

School districts in most states calculate pay based on seniority and level of education. For example, teachers who get master's degrees generally get a pay bump.

In a massive survey of the nation's teachers released in March, most said they value non-monetary rewards, such as time to collaborate with other teachers and a supportive school leadership, over higher salaries. Only 28% felt performance pay would have a strong impact and 30% felt performance pay would have no impact at all. The survey was conducted by Harris Interactive and paid for by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and Scholastic Inc.

Still, lawmakers and education officials in many states are pushing the idea.

Washington, D.C., schools just reached a tentative agreement with their teachers' union that would allow teachers to earn annual bonuses for student progress on standardized tests, among other benchmarks.

In Georgia, Gov. Sonny Perdue is pushing for a law requiring teacher salaries to be based on student test scores and other academic factors such as SAT prep courses, rather than years of experience and education.

Oklahoma lawmakers are considering a similar bill that would create a pilot program for teacher bonuses. In Louisiana, Colorado, Florida and Minnesota, where a few local districts have been offering merit pay to teachers for years, lawmakers and governors are aiming to create statewide programs.

The states and D.C. hope to win some of the $4.35 billion in highly competitive federal "Race the Top" money available this year to states that embrace education reforms like merit pay and charter schools. Tennessee and Delaware were initial winners of the money, garnering $600 million in part because of their teacher merit pay programs and their use of student achievement data in teacher evaluations.

Other states — particularly those like Georgia, Florida and Colorado that were among the 16 finalists for the grant competition — are hoping to get performance pay laws passed in time to reapply for the money in June.

"We want to reward our educators who are truly making gains with our students," said Perdue, who has used Georgia's position as a finalist for the federal money to urge lawmakers to pass his performance pay bill. "To some, it's become more of a job than a calling or a passion."

Powerful teachers' unions in many states are fighting performance pay proposals, arguing that they lack thoughtful planning for how performance will be measured, and advocating that teachers should instead be paid more overall.

"If you don't engage teachers in the process of what the incentives are — they put them out there, and teachers don't understand them and don't believe they will work or be workable — they are not going to be incentives that mean anything. They'll actually do the opposite. They will demoralize people," said Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers.

Meanwhile, trouble brews in some states' merit pay programs that already exist. A judge ruled recently that an Arizona performance pay program is unconstitutional because it's open to only 28 out of more than 230 school districts

In Florida, just eight of 67 districts participate, although a bill before lawmakers would create a $900 million pot to woo more districts to the program.