231-922-9460 | Google +

Showing posts with label Coal Mining. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Coal Mining. Show all posts

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Labor Department Asks Court To Close Massey Mine In Kentucky

NPR


The Labor Department took an unprecedented step against a Kentucky coal mine Wednesday, asking that a federal judge shut it down immediately to protect the lives of those who work there.

In filing for a preliminary injunction in U.S. District Court, the government cites persistently dangerous conditions in Massey Energy's Freedom Mine No. 1 in Pike County. The action — the toughest enforcement action available to federal regulators — would shut down the mine until safety hazards are addressed and Massey Energy demonstrates it can operate the mine safely.

The Freedom Mine employs about 130 miners and was cited for safety violations more than 700 times this year alone.

The move is viewed by mine safety experts as one response to the deadly explosion in April at Massey's Upper Big Branch mine in West Virginia.  Twenty-nine mine workers died in that tragedy, which has triggered civil and criminal investigations.

For 33 years, the agency has had the authority to take mining companies to federal court when they have serious and persistent safety violations. But this "injunctive relief" section of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act has not been invoked until now.

Section 108(a)(2) of that law authorizes the Labor Department to seek restraining orders, preliminary or permanent injunctions and other federal court orders when a mining company "is engaged in a pattern of violation" that "constitutes a continuing hazard to the health or safety of miners."

The non-union Freedom Energy Mine No. 1 "has a high risk level for a fatal accident...on any given day" writes James Poynter, an assistant district manager at the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA), in a document filed in federal court on Wednesday.

"MSHA continues to find serious and threatening conditions at this mine," Poynter adds, even after federal officials met multiple times with Freedom Energy managers about conditions at the mine. The most recent meeting cited took place in July.

"MSHA has used all the tools available to it in the regulatory scheme in an attempt to bring this operator into compliance," Poynter concludes.

Massey Energy was not aware of the court action when contacted by NPR. Shane Harvey, Massey vice president and general counsel, provided this immediate response:

"We are checking into this now. Regardless of what the complaint says, we are committed to running Freedom Energy and all our operations safely and will take whatever steps are necessary to ensure the safety of our miners," Harvey says. "As you will recall, we idled all underground operations last Friday to conduct additional safety training and to identify and correct hazards."

Freedom Energy Mine No. 1 was included in that safety training and Massey CEO Don Blankenship personally presented the safety briefing during Freedom's day shift and at two other company mines.

Last week, Blankenship spoke generically about older and larger mines like Freedom that also generate more safety violations.

"They're getting those violations not because we feel like the mine is more dangerous or because we're not trying real hard but there's so much area" underground, Blankenship said. Some, he continued, have millions of square feet and conveyor belts miles long, "and if you want to find (safety violations) you can pretty much find that in a mine of that size."

"The bigger, older mines are much more difficult to avoid violations," Blankenship said.

Freedom Energy Mine No. 1 had a federal safety violations rate in 2009 that precisely matches the national average. But so far this year, Freedom's actual number of violations exceeds its total for all of last year.

The injury rate at the mine last year is close to half the national rate for 2009, according to an NPR analysis of federal mine safety data. That same data indicates that no deaths have occurred at Freedom since 1995, the first year fatality data is reported on MSHA's website.

Still, "the risk of harm to miners is much worse at Freedom than it is at other comparable mines," MSHA's Poynter contends.

Court Supervision

In its federal court complaint, the Labor Department seeks a preliminary injunction placing the mine under court supervision and shutting it down until safety hazards are addressed and Massey Energy demonstrates it can operate the mine safely.

The court order the agency seeks would require Massey Energy to continue to pay Freedom miners during a shutdown.

Court documents and state and federal records obtained by NPR cite persistent safety violations involving accumulations of flammable and explosive coal and coal dust, the threat of rock falls, ventilation or air flow in the mine, hazardous electrical equipment, spotting and recording dangers and emergency evacuation procedures.

MSHA already has the authority to shut down all or parts of mines for serious safety violations but mining resumes as soon as immediate problems are addressed.

Fines are also levied by MSHA but mining companies routinely appeal fines and it can take years for those appeals to be resolved. Right now, more than 18,000 citations and fines are waiting for administrative court action.

"What I think has happened over many, many years is that there's a growing frustration with the citation, abatement, penalty process where the mine operators continue to violate the same standards and there is no permanent fix to serious problems," says Ed Clair, MSHA's former top lawyer, who spent more than two decades at the agency.

History Of Safety Violations

The Freedom Mine has a history of serious and repeated safety violations. Two hundred of its federal citations this year are classified as "serious and substantial," according to MSHA records, and 50 are listed as an "unwarrantable failure" to comply with mine safety law.

"Unwarrantable failure means you knew there was a violation and didn’t fix it or you should have known…because it was open and obvious and you didn’t fix it," says Tony Oppegard, a former mine safety prosecutor and regulator who represents coal miners in lawsuits against mining companies.

"This is a troubled mine," Oppegard adds. "And it's long past time that that (injunctive relief) section of the law (is) used."

MSHA records show that the biggest repeated problem at Freedom is failure to clean up or neutralize loose coal and coal dust, which can feed and accelerate fires and explosions.

Freedom is also a "gassy" mine —- 1 million to 2 million cubic feet of methane gas naturally seeps in every day, according to MSHA records.  Methane is highly explosive at certain concentrations so the daily presence of such large quantities of the gas increases the potential for explosions.

Mines are required to remove excessive coal and coal dust and spray the mine with crushed limestone or "rock dust" to diminish the possibility of ignition. But documents filed in federal court cite numerous incidents involving loose coal and coal dust at the Freedom Mine:

Nov. 10, 2008 — Inspectors issue a citation for "high negligence" and an unwarrantable failure after finding loose coal and coal dust as much as two feet deep and stretching 140 feet. The citation reads: "The operator knew and had knowledge of this hazardous condition."

May 14, 2009 - An inspector notes highly explosive "float" coal dust spread more than two miles underground.

Nov. 13, 2009 - After another coal dust violation, an inspector notes it "took a total of 14 miners for a total of 10 (nine-hour) shifts" to clean up the excessive coal. "Mine management has failed to abate" an earlier coal dust citation, another inspector writes. "Loose coal is still present...(and) the conveyor belt and bottom return rollers are turning in the combustible material for a distance of 12 feet in length and approximately 2 feet deep"

(Machinery churning in loose coal can create enough friction to ignite a fire or explosion, according to another inspector in a separate citation.)

April 12, 2010 - After citing Freedom for coal dust in and around machinery and electrical components that can produce sparks, an inspector wrote: "This condition is obvious and extensive…and the operator has been placed on notice."

May 20, 2010 - After yet another coal dust citation, an inspector notes: "Operator has been cited for this condition 281 times in twenty four months."

Safety inspections and reports compiled by MSHA and Kentucky's Office of Mine Safety and Licensing cite repeated violations involving rock falls. An MSHA inspector noted 117 such violations in the last two years. Poynter writes in his court declaration that two miners would have been killed in one of six rock falls since August if a power outage hadn't kept them away.

Rock falls at Freedom can be massive. State and federal accident reports describe one 250 feet long, 18 feet wide and 9 feet thick.

Ventilation is also listed as a persistent problem. Proper ventilation sweeps away explosive and toxic gases. But federal inspectors found dead or little airflow at times and air flowing in the wrong direction.

Getting Tough

"This mine is, in essence, on a downward slide," says Celeste Monforton, a former federal mine safety official who is one of the independent investigators reviewing the Upper Big Branch disaster. "This is the exact type of mine, I would imagine, the drafters of the Mine Act had envisioned when they put in this very serious provision that would allow the agency to go to court."

Monforton reviewed the federal safety record of the Freedom Mine at NPR's request.

"Despite the agency's efforts to send a message to the mine that they are violating the law, in their subsequent inspections they even had more citations and orders than in the previous inspection period," Monforton says.

Monforton calls injunctive relief "the nuclear option" because it's considered MSHA's toughest enforcement tool. And the agency has been under pressure to get tough since the loss of 29 lives at the Upper Big Branch mine in April.

A few days after the final victims were removed from the mine, President Obama told reporters gathered in the White House Rose Garden that it was time to consider all of the government's enforcement tools to protect miners.

"We need to take a hard look at our own practices and our own procedures to ensure that we're pursuing mine safety as relentlessly as we responsibly can," Obama said.

At a Senate hearing in May, Assistant Labor Secretary Joe Main said the agency was considering injunctive relief cases "to go after and shut down mines that have records like Upper Big Branch."

And in June, federal mine safety chief Kevin Stricklin wrote this about Freedom Energy Mine #1 in an internal e-mail obtained by NPR: "We need to use this mine as a test case."

A 'Wake-Up Call'


Former MSHA solicitor Ed Clair says the agency has resisted going to court in the past because it had other options that seemed to work. He says mine deaths were declining until 2006.

Clair also sees risk in putting mine safety regulation in the hands of a federal judge.  That puts the resolution of safety problems in a judge's control, Clair suggests, and leaves the regulators on the sidelines.

A judge may also have this question:  If this mine is so dangerous, why did it take the Labor Department this long to go to court? It's been almost five months, after all, since Stricklin cited the Freedom Mine as the test case.

A judge's rejection of the case is the biggest risk, Clair says, "And that could establish a very adverse precedent for using this provision and perhaps somehow otherwise circumscribe the agency's enforcement authority."

But with 56 coal miners dead in five disasters since 2006, Clair sees the wisdom in breaking precedent.

Mine safety expert Celeste Monforton believes the most recent tragedy has a lot to do with the Labor Department's action now.

"The Upper Big Branch mine disaster was the harshest wake-up call imaginable," Monforton says. "I'm not sure the moment would have come if not for the 29 lives lost."

The first hearing in the Freedom Mine case is expected in the next several weeks in a federal court in eastern Kentucky.

Saturday, April 17, 2010

Lawsuits Filed Against Massey Energy

The Wall Street Journal

Labor Department Asks for Independent Review of MSHA Mine Probe

The Labor Department said Friday that it has asked an independent team of occupational safety experts to examine the U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration's internal review of its actions at the West Virginia mine where 29 workers were killed in an explosion last week.

In a written statement, Labor Secretary Hilda Solis said she has asked the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health to identify a team with relevant experience to provide an independent analysis of MSHA's internal review. Ms. Solis said that while she is confident that MSHA will conduct "a thorough and complete review" of its own actions at the Upper Big Branch mine in the period leading up to the April 5 explosion, an independent analysis of the review is needed "to ensure accountability." She added that both the MSHA internal review and the independent analysis of that review will be made public.

"This independent evaluation will help ensure that we're doing everything we can to protect the health and safety of America's miners," Ms. Solis said.

Two lawsuits were filed against Massey Energy Co. in the wake of the April 5 accident, one by the widow of a miner and another by a shareholder group.

Marlene Griffith, the widow of William I. Griffith, filed a suit alleging that "reckless and negligent conduct" by Massey resulted in Mr. Griffith's death. The eight-page complaint seeking damages under West Virginia's wrongful death statute was filed in Raleigh County Circuit Court Thursday and names Massey as well as its subsidiaries Performance Coal and Massey Coal Services as defendants.

Separately, a Massey shareholder filed a complaint in Kanawha County Circuit Court against CEO Don Blankenship and Massey's board of directors, alleging that they failed to ensure the company complied with worker safety laws and ignored "red flags" in the months leading up to the accident.

The complaint, filed by lawyers Thursday, alleges that Mr. Blankenship and other board members "have caused and will continue to cause severe injury" to Massey by "consciously ignoring" the company's legal obligations and exposing the company to "a substantial threat of monetary liability." The suit seeks unspecified damages as well as reimbursement for the costs of bringing the complaint.

The complaint was brought by Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust, a New York-based trust that owns more than 1,000 shares of Massey common stock. The trust settled a similar lawsuit in 2008 over Massey's handling of environmental and safety issues. As part of that settlement, Massey agreed to increase oversight of the coal company's environmental and safety compliance.

A spokesman for Richmond-based Massey couldn't be reached Friday to comment on the lawsuits. In a recent statement, the company defended its safety practices and said, "We strive to be in compliance with all regulations at all times." The company has 30 days after being served with the complaints to respond in court, according to a West Virginia attorney.

The accident at the Upper Big Branch mine in Montcoal, West Va., is the worst coal mining disaster in 40 years. On Thursday, the Mine Safety and Health Administration released a preliminary report on the accident and noted that the mine had "a significant history of safety violations" and that the mine and Massey were being watched closely by the agency.

The lawsuit brought by Ms. Griffith says that William Griffith began working as a coal miner in 1974, shortly after graduating from high school, and that he began working for Performance Coal in 1992 at the Upper Big Branch mine.

Mark Moreland, a Charleston, West Va., attorney representing Mr. Griffith's estate, said in an interview that Mr. Griffith's family wanted to have representation during ongoing investigations of the accident. "Massey will have a representative at all those investigations, and our client felt that they deserved representation," he said.

The complaint includes inspection-related material previously released by MSHA. "We looked at the history of this mine through the MSHA Web site and it's clear that Massey and Performance were operating in a reckless manner," Mr. Moreland said.